The curiosity gap is the tension we feel between what we know and what we want to know. In video, an open loop raises a specific question early and answers it later, which motivates viewers to keep watching. It works best when the question matters to the viewer and the answer is real; unanswered or exaggerated loops damage trust.
Curiosity is the engine behind most hooks. Understanding it helps you use it without tricking viewers.
The psychology
George Loewenstein's information-gap theory proposes that curiosity arises when attention is drawn to a gap in one's knowledge. Such gaps produce a feeling of deprivation that people are motivated to reduce, and curiosity is strongest when we already know a little about the topic (Loewenstein, 1994). Two practical implications:
- Specific gaps beat vague ones. "The one setting that doubled our watch time" is a gap; "some tips" is not.
- Some knowledge helps. Give context first so the viewer knows enough to care.
Curiosity vs clickbait
Linguistic research on clickbait describes how headlines withhold information to create a curiosity gap, and how this relies on readers expecting relevance (Scott, 2021). Data from headline rewrites showed most curiosity features increased clicks, but no feature reliably predicted success on its own (Kuiken et al., 2017). On YouTube, clicks without satisfaction show up as a steep retention drop.
| Honest curiosity gap | Clickbait |
|---|---|
| The answer is in the video | The answer is missing or trivial |
| The gap matters to the viewer | The gap is shock for its own sake |
| Paid off at a clear moment | Strung along to the end |
How to build open loops in a video
- Main loop (hook): "By the end you'll know why our cheapest video got the most leads."
- Section loops: end each section with a teaser: "That works, until you hit the problem in step 3."
- Visual loops: show part of a result, reveal the rest later.
- Payoff markers: say clearly when you close a loop: "So here's why the cheap video won."
Mistakes
- Opening three loops and closing one
- Holding the payoff until the last second
- Using loops in every sentence, which feels manipulative
Conclusion
Use one specific, honest main question and small loops between sections, and always pay them off. See the best video hooks and story structure for YouTube videos.
Sources
- Loewenstein (1994). The psychology of curiosity: A review and reinterpretation. Psychological Bulletin
- Scott (2021). You won't believe what's in this paper! Clickbait, relevance and the curiosity gap. Journal of Pragmatics
- Kuiken et al. (2017). Effective headlines of newspaper articles in a digital environment. Digital Journalism